The agent you choose will shape your entire real estate experience—from the homes you see to the price you pay or receive. A great agent protects your interests and simplifies a complex process, while a poor fit can cost you money and create unnecessary stress.
This guide walks you through how to research candidates, what questions to ask in interviews, which credentials actually matter, and the red flags that signal you should keep looking.
Why Choosing the Right Real Estate Agent Matters
Choosing a real estate agent comes down to defining your criteria, researching candidates through referrals and online directories, interviewing thoroughly, and verifying credentials and track records. The right agent advocates for your financial interests, negotiates on your behalf, and walks you through a transaction that can feel overwhelming if you're doing it alone.
A poor choice, on the other hand, can cost you money and create stress during an already demanding process. Your agent becomes your advisor and problem-solver, so taking time to evaluate your options pays off in both peace of mind and results.
How to Research Real Estate Agents Before You Reach Out
Before you contact anyone, a bit of homework helps you identify serious candidates and avoid wasting time on agents who aren't the right fit. Think of this as the research phase before the interview phase.
Ask Homeowners and Past Clients for Referrals
Start by asking neighbors, coworkers, and friends who recently bought or sold a home. Firsthand experiences reveal how an agent handles challenges, communicates under pressure, and delivers on promises.
When someone shares their experience, ask specific questions: Was the agent responsive? Did they feel informed throughout the process? Would they hire that agent again? Referrals from people you trust remain one of the most reliable ways to find quality representation.
Verify Licensing and Check for Disciplinary Actions
Every state requires real estate agents to hold a valid license. In Florida, you can look up an agent's license status through the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) website.
While you're there, check for any disciplinary actions or complaints. A clean record indicates the agent operates ethically and follows state regulations.
Review Current Listings and Recent Sales
Take a look at the agent's current listings online. Pay attention to the quality of listing photos, accuracy of property descriptions, and how pricing compares to similar homes in the area.
This gives you a preview of how they'll market your home if you're selling, or how thoroughly they'll search for properties if you're buying.
Attend Open Houses to See Agents in Action
Open houses offer a low-pressure way to observe agents in their element. Notice how they interact with visitors, answer questions, and present the property.
You'll get a sense of their professionalism and knowledge without any commitment on your part.
How to Choose a Real Estate Agent Based on Credentials and Experience
Credentials in real estate include licenses, designations, and certifications. Experience isn't just years in the business—it's relevant transaction history in your price range and property type.
Professional Designations and Certifications
Some agents pursue additional training beyond their license. Common designations include:
- CRS (Certified Residential Specialist): Advanced training in residential transactions
- ABR (Accredited Buyer's Representative): Specialized focus on buyer representation
- SRES (Seniors Real Estate Specialist): Training for working with older adults
Designations indicate an agent has invested in specialized knowledge, though they don't guarantee quality on their own.
Transaction Volume and Sales Track Record
Consistent activity matters more than one exceptional year. Look for agents actively closing deals in your price range and property type.
Ask how many transactions they completed in the past 12 months and what their average sale price looks like. This tells you whether their experience aligns with your situation.
Full-Time Commitment to Real Estate
Part-time agents may struggle to accommodate your schedule or respond quickly when time-sensitive situations arise. A full-time agent typically offers greater availability for showings, negotiations, and urgent questions.
Ask directly: Is real estate your full-time job?
Questions to Ask When Interviewing Real Estate Agents
Treat your first meeting like a job interview—you're hiring someone to represent your interests. Interview at least two or three agents before making a decision.
How Long Have You Worked in Residential Real Estate
Tenure matters, though it isn't everything. A newer agent with strong mentorship and recent training may outperform a complacent veteran who hasn't adapted to current market conditions.
What Is Your Track Record on Price Negotiations
Ask how close their final sale prices are to initial offers. For sellers, this reveals how well they price homes and negotiate. For buyers, it shows whether they can secure favorable terms.
Will You Represent Me Exclusively
Exclusive representation means the agent works solely for your interests. Dual agency, where one agent represents both buyer and seller, creates potential conflicts of interest.
Ask the agent to explain their approach and confirm they'll advocate for you alone.
How Will You Keep Me Informed Throughout the Process
Communication breakdown is a top complaint in real estate transactions. Ask about their preferred methods—calls, texts, emails—and how often you can expect updates.
Make sure their communication style matches what you prefer.
Can You Provide References from Recent Clients
Request contact information for their last few clients. When you reach out, ask about the agent's responsiveness, problem-solving skills, and whether they would hire them again.
References offer insight that credentials alone can't provide.
Can You Recommend Trusted Lenders and Service Providers
A well-connected agent has relationships with mortgage lenders, inspectors, and contractors. This network can streamline your transaction and help you avoid unreliable vendors.
How to Evaluate an Agent's Local Market Knowledge
Local expertise means understanding neighborhood pricing trends, school districts, development plans, and community character. It's not just having a license to work in the area—it's knowing the area inside and out.
Neighborhood Expertise and Recent Sales Activity
Ask the agent about recent sales in your target neighborhoods. Test their knowledge with specific questions about the areas you're considering.
An agent who knows the local market can spot opportunities and potential issues that someone unfamiliar with the area might miss. For example, they might know that a particular street floods during heavy rain or that a new development is planned nearby.
Connections to Local Inspectors and Contractors
Trusted local connections help with inspections, repairs, and closing logistics. An agent embedded in the community has vetted professionals ready to assist when you need them.
Why Communication Style Matters When Choosing an Agent
Even a highly qualified agent can frustrate you if their communication style doesn't match your expectations. Pay attention to how they communicate during your initial conversations—it's a preview of what to expect throughout your transaction.
Here's what to evaluate:
- Responsiveness: How quickly do they return calls and texts?
- Clarity: Do they explain things in plain language or rely on jargon?
- Proactiveness: Do they update you without being asked?
- Listening: Do they understand your priorities or push their own agenda?
The Difference Between a Realtor and a Real Estate Agent
All Realtors are real estate agents, but not all agents are Realtors. A Realtor is a member of the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and agrees to follow a specific code of ethics.
| Real Estate Agent | Realtor | |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed to practice | Yes | Yes |
| NAR member | No | Yes |
| Bound by NAR Code of Ethics | No | Yes |
Both can be excellent—membership alone doesn't guarantee quality. Focus on the individual's track record, communication, and fit with your situation.
Red Flags to Watch For When Choosing a Real Estate Agent
Certain warning signs indicate you may want to keep looking. Here's what to watch for.
Part-Time Agents with Limited Availability
Part-time agents may not be available when you need them most. Real estate transactions often require quick responses, and delays can cost you opportunities.
No Recent Transaction History in Your Area
An agent without recent local sales may lack current market knowledge and neighborhood connections. Ask specifically about their activity in your target area over the past year.
Poor Responsiveness During Initial Contact
If they're slow to respond before they have your business, expect worse after. First impressions reveal their communication habits.
Pressure Tactics or Unrealistic Promises
Agents who guarantee sale prices or push you toward quick decisions may prioritize their commission over your interests. A trustworthy agent presents realistic expectations and respects your timeline.
How to Make Your Final Decision on a Real Estate Agent
After your research and interviews, weigh the evidence:
- Trust your instincts: Do you feel comfortable and heard?
- Consider the facts: Credentials, track record, references, and local knowledge all matter
- Prioritize fit: The best agent on paper may not be the best agent for you
Choosing an agent is personal—you'll work closely together through a significant transaction. The right fit combines competence with compatibility.
Work with a Central Florida Agent Who Puts You First
Choosing the right agent means finding someone with local expertise, clear communication, and a genuine commitment to your goals. Whether you're buying your first home, selling to move up, or relocating to Central Florida, the process works best when you have a steady, supportive partner guiding you through each step.
If you're searching in Central Florida, Jorge of Orlando brings deep neighborhood knowledge and a service approach built around honest, friendly guidance. When you're ready to take the next step, we're here to help.
FAQs About Choosing a Real Estate Agent
What is the 80/20 rule for realtors?
The 80/20 rule suggests that roughly 20% of agents close 80% of transactions in any market. This is why researching an agent's actual activity level matters—you want someone who's actively working, not just licensed.
What is the 3 3 3 rule in real estate?
The 3 3 3 rule is a follow-up guideline some agents use: reaching out three times across three different methods over three weeks. Practices vary by agent and brokerage, so ask your agent directly about their communication approach.
How do real estate agents get paid?
Agents typically earn a commission paid at closing, calculated as a percentage of the sale price. This commission is usually split between the buyer's and seller's agents according to the listing agreement.
Is it better to use the same agent to buy and sell your home?
Using the same agent for both transactions can simplify coordination, especially when timing matters. However, evaluate whether your agent has strong expertise in both buying and selling before committing to this approach.
Check out this article next
